Chris Simms calls out Jalen Hurts: ‘Most overrated player in football’

Chris Simms’ critique of Jalen Hurts isn’t just a passing comment; it’s a belief he’s stood by since Hurts’ first season with the Philadelphia Eagles. Simms argues that Hurts benefits greatly from the talent surrounding him, particularly the team’s offensive line, which he considers the best in football. He suggests that this support masks Hurts’ limitations as a quarterback and leads to his being overrated.

Simms draws comparisons to other quarterbacks like Kyler Murray, implying that if they were in Hurts’ position, they would garner even more praise due to their individual talents. He even controversially suggested that the Eagles could still perform well with someone like Gardner Minshew under center, indicating a lack of faith in Hurts’ abilities to elevate the team.

The narrative surrounding Hurts becomes more complex when considering the team’s trajectory. Despite his individual success and Pro Bowl selection, the Eagles experienced a significant downturn in the second half of the 2023 season, coinciding with Hurts’ struggles with turnovers. Simms highlights this as evidence of Hurts’ limitations and suggests that the team may need to reevaluate their quarterback situation moving forward.

Hurts has been a very successful QB with Philly

However, it’s important to note that Hurts still achieved personal milestones during the 2023 season, including career-high numbers in completions, yards, and touchdowns. His accomplishments demonstrate that he’s capable of success within the right circumstances, even if there are areas for improvement.

Ultimately, the debate over Jalen Hurts’ value as a quarterback continues to rage on, with supporters pointing to his achievements and potential, while critics like Simms emphasize his perceived shortcomings and the team’s collective contributions to his success. As the Eagles navigate their future, the question of whether they stick with Hurts or explore other options remains unanswered, but one thing is clear: the conversation isn’t likely to die down anytime soon.